Featured

The Architects of Wisconsin Golf

This is far from a comprehensive list of all golf architects that have done work in Wisconsin. Instead, this list is limited to the architects that I believe have had the greatest impact on the golf landscape in the state. Impact is difficult to measure, but I believe it can be calculated by the number of courses they designed and/or the influence of their courses on Wisconsin golf’s image. This list is not necessarily a reflection of whether I like or dislike the designs of a particular architect, but in each case the architect in focus has enhanced the state of golf in Wisconsin.

Larry Packard (1912-2014)

Photo Credit: World Golf Report

Born in Massachusetts, Edward Lawrence (Larry) Packard attended Massachusetts State College and graduated with a degree in Landscape Architecture. He started off his career working as a landscape architect for the National Park Service in Maine, the U.S. Corps of Engineers in Massachusetts, and finally for the Chicago Park District. In 1946, Packard decided to venture into the world of golf course architecture and began to work under architect Robert Bruce Harris. He remained on Harris’ staff for eight years before teaming up with Brent Wadsworth to form the design firm of Packard and Wadsworth. Not too long after, the two split apart and formed their own firms, Packard’s focused on golf course design and Wadsworth’s on the construction of golf courses. Larry Packard was very influential on the design philosophies of the time. He pioneered the trend of gentler sculpting and free form shaping of course elements. Packard was known for easing golfers into the round with an easy first few holes and implemented his double dogleg design at nearly every one of his courses. He was also one of the first architects to raise environmental concerns about the profession and advocated for using wastewater to irrigate golf courses. Despite entering the field of golf course design in 1946, it took Packard until 1961 to begin working heavily in Wisconsin, however, once he got his start in the state, he rapidly transformed the golfing landscape like no other architect had done before. He went on to design or renovate over 25 courses throughout the state, more than any other architect in the history of Wisconsin golf, other than Art Johnson or perhaps Tom Bendelow. In the 1970s, his son Roger joined his side and together they worked on several projects, launching Roger’s successful career both in and out of Wisconsin.

Courses Designed: Bass Lake GC, Baraboo CC, Brown County GC, Chaska GC (with Roger Packard), Glacier Wood GC (Iola Community GC), Lincoln Hills CC, Mascoutin GC (with Roger Packard), Naga-Waukee GC, Oakwood Park GC, Peninsula State Park GC, Rib Mountain GC, River Island GC, Skyline GC (Black River Falls GC with Brent Wadsworth), Stevens Point CC, Wausau GC, Western Lakes GC (Tumblebrook GC), Westview CC.

Courses Remodeled or Added to: Bulls Eye CC, Chenequa GC, La Crosse CC, Merrill Hills CC, Minocqua CC, Muskego Lakes CC (with Roger Packard), Stevens Point CC, Watertown CC (with Brent Wadsworth).

Arthur “Art” Johnson (1927-2010)

Native of Madison, Art Johnson is one of the most unknown, yet highly influential architects in Wisconsin golf. In a profession that relies on boosting one’s image and marketing themselves, Johnson didn’t play that game. Johnson worked on the most golf courses in Wisconsin, having designed 11 percent of the state’s courses, but you would never know that by talking to him. He served the Madison community as the head of park planning for the city of Madison’s park division, where he passionately worked to preserve parkland during a time of rapid urban development by designing and building public parks and golf courses. His golf courses resembled his personality, never flashy or in-your-face, but instead very modest and low-key. Perhaps illustrated best by the fact that I couldn’t even find a photo of him. His personality was refreshing in the world of inflated egos that too often plagues the profession. Golf in the state of Wisconsin was forever changed when Johnson decided to begin designing golf courses, preserving the natural features that make the state great, as well as providing access to low-cost public golf courses throughout the state.

Courses Designed/Remodeled: Alpine Valley GC, Black River CC, Castle Rock GC, Cecelia’s GC, Clintonville Riverside GC, Devils Head Resort (Glacier & Prairie Glen Courses), Edelweiss Chalet GC, Glacier Wood GC, Koshkonong Mounds CC, Monona GC, Oaks GC at Christmas Mountain Village, Odana Hills GC, Pine Trail GC, Pleasant View GC (Lakes & Woods Courses), Portage GC, River Run GC, Saddle Ridge GC, Spring Valley GC, Telemark CC, Tumbledown Trails GC, Waushara CC (Bridges, Lakeview, and Westwoods Courses), Wild Rock GC (Woods Course), Yahara Hills GC (East & West Courses).

George Hansen (1891-1951)

George Hansen was another revolutionary figure in Wisconsin golf history. He served as the superintendent for the Milwaukee Parks Department for over thirty years. In his time with the Parks Department, Hansen single-handedly built the public golf system that exists today. He got his start by remodeling an existing nine-hole course in the area and that led to him designing and building five new courses around the city, including Brown Deer Park GC which because of his efforts hosted the 1951 USGA PubLinks Championship. Unfortunately, he passed away before the event occurred. He left behind a legacy in the city of Milwaukee, as he helped provide accessible golf courses to the city’s residents. Not only did he help grow the game in the community by building these golf courses, his best course, Brown Deer Park went on to host a PGA Tour event, the Greater Milwaukee Open, for 16 years and was the site of Tiger Woods’ first professional start in 1996.

Courses Designed: Brown Deer Park GC, Currie Park GC, Grant Park GC, Greenfield Park GC, Whitnall GC.

Pete Dye (1925-2020) & Alice Dye (1927-2019)

Photo Credit: The A Position

Paul “Pete” Dye Jr. grew up in Urbana, Ohio and went on to attend Rollins College and Stetson University in Florida. Pete met his future wife while they were both attending Rollins College. After college, the couple married and moved to Alice’s hometown of Indianapolis, where both Pete and Alice worked as a life insurance salespersons. Both were great amateur golfers, but it was Alice that had the more illustrious career. She won seven Indiana Women’s Amateur titles, three Florida Women’s Amateur titles, five Women’s Western Senior titles, and two USGA Women’s Senior Amateur Championships. These titles resulted in her induction into the Indiana Golf Hall of Fame. While Alice exited the insurance business in 1952 after the birth of their first son, Perry, Pete continued until 1959, when he decided to quit and venture out into the world of golf design. The duo formed a design company and began to design and build layouts in small towns throughout Central Indiana. They expanded into other parts of the Midwest before the tandem decided to visit the historic courses of Scotland. This was an invaluable experience for Pete, as he began to incorporate many of the themes that he observed into his future designs. These characteristics included small greens, pot bunkers, railroad ties, native roughs, and undulating fairways. Though Pete tends to get the majority of the credit for the couple’s designs, the duo was inseparable in both life and golf design. In fact, in the design company’s youth, Pete was unable to read a topography map and left it up to Alice to decipher. Alice also devoted her time to determine where to place tees and hazards to provide strategy and challenge for female golfers, which she considered her most important contribution to golf architecture.

Pete got his first start in Wisconsin in 1971, when he laid out the Highlands Course at Lake Geneva Resort alongside Jack Nicklaus, originally called Americana Lake Geneva GC (Briarpatch), but he did not return for work in the state until 1987 he was contacted by Herb Kohler to build River Run GC, now known as Blackwolf Run. The course opened in 1988 with 18 holes but was expanded to 27 in 1989 and eventually to 36 in 1990. The two courses operated for nearly a decade before Herb Kohler decided to add two additional courses on a former Army airfield in the nearby town of Haven. These two courses were the Straits and Irish Courses at Whsitling Straits. Between Blackwolf Run and Whistling Straits, Kohler and Dye were responsible for changing the landscape of Wisconsin golf by bringing several major championships to the state, including two US Women’s Opens (Blackwolf Run), three PGA Championships (Whistling Straits), and an upcoming Ryder Cup (Whistling Straits).

Courses Designed: Americana Lake Geneva GC (Highlands at Grand Geneva Resort), Blackwolf Run (Meadow Valleys & River), Whistling Straits (Irish & Straits).

Tom Bendelow (1872-1936)

Photo Credit: Cultural Landscape Foundation

Born in Aberdeen Scotland in 1872, Tom Bendelow learned the game early on in Scotland and made several trips to St. Andrews as a young boy. He moved to the United States in 1885 and started his career as a typesetter for the New York Herald. When he saw an advertisement in the classified section looking for a young golfer to teach a family the game in 1895, he responded and was hired by the Pratt family (founders of Standard Oil). Bendelow’s laid out a short course on the Pratt estate on Long Island. This would be the first of over 400 designs in Bendelow’s career. Shortly thereafter, he began to layout several rudimentary golf courses around New York. He was then hired by A.G. Spalding as part of Spalding’s sporting goods company and began to layout basic golf courses throughout the country. After World War I, he was transferred to Chicago and in 1920 he left the sporting goods company to take over as chief golf architect for American Park Builders, replacing William Langford. In this new position, Bendelow worked on refining and mastering his craft. He began to create more sophisticated and detailed plans and even started creating plaster models to visualize proposed green contours. Despite the evolution of Bendelow’s work, his reputation in the history of golf and golf architecture is focused on his simple and somewhat primitive design process that characterized his early years. Whatever is thought about Bendelow’s design philosophy, there is no doubt he was a pioneer of golf and golf architecture in America, which is why he was coined the nickname, “Johnny Appleseed of American Golf.”

Although Art Johnson and Larry Packard are responsible for the most courses currently in operation in the state of Wisconsin, Bendelow may have designed a similar number, if not more courses than either of them. Unfortunately, many of his designs no longer exist or bear little resemblance to what he laid out 100 years ago, so there is great debate on whether some courses are the creations of Bendelow. The most comprehensive list totals the number of his designs in Wisconsin at 38, of which only 21 still exist in some form of Bendelow’s work. Since his philosophy, especially early on, was to provide access to the game to as many people as possible, many of his designs were basic and rudimentary, so as time went on and the game grew, many golfers “outgrew” the designs of Bendelow, which led to the destruction or renovation of a large chunk of his courses, especially since many of his layouts were only nine holes.

Courses Designed: Algoma CC (Lakeshore GC)*, Beulah Lake GC*, Big Foot CC, Blue Mound G&CC*, Burr Oaks GC*, Chenequa GC, Cherry Hills Golf & Lodge, Country Club Estates, CC of Beloit*, Fond du Lac CC (South Hills CC), Fond du Lac Town & Country*, Fox River CC*, Geneva Lake Yacht & GC*, George Williams College GC*, Lake Lawn GC, Lake Park GC, Lake Wandawega GC*, Lakeside GC – Pewaukee*, Lakside CC – Manitowoc* (now Branch River), Lincoln Park GC, Manitowoc GC (Elks Club)*, Meadow Links GC, Milwaukee CC*, Nakoma CC, Northernaire CC (Three Lakes GC), Old Hickory GC, Oshkosh CC, Pine Lake CC*, Quit-Qui-Oc GC, Racine CC, Riverview CC*, Sheboygan Town & CC, Tripoli CC (Univ. Club of Milwaukee), Tuscumbia CC, Washington Park GC – Racine, Wausau CC, West Park GC*, Woodmont CC (New Berlin Hills).

William Langford (1887-1977) & Theodore Moreau (1890-1942)

Born in Illinois in 1887, William B. Langford was introduced to the game of golf as a result of a rehabilitation program after suffering from polio in his childhood years. He developed into a great amateur player and won three NCAA team national championships as a member of the Yale golf team. Langford then attended Columbia University where he earned a master’s degree in Mining Engineering. He returned to Chicago and worked as a golf architect for the American Park Builders, and then in 1918 he paired up with engineer Theodore J. Moreau to form his own design firm as the post-WWI course design boom began. Langford tended to focus on the design aspect of the business, whereas Moreau handled the construction aspect, with a few exceptions. Langford and Moreau were the most productive architects in the Midwest and South during the Golden Age of Golf Design (1920s to WWII). The tandem is known for their use of the steam shovel to produce bold and dramatic features and green sites. Their most notable design, Lawsonia Links, was completed in 1930 and marked an end to their careers together as the Great Depression hit and World War II followed shortly thereafter. They are the ultimate, “what could have been,” when it comes to golf architects as their work continued to improve throughout their partnership before it was cut short and officially ended in the early 1940s. Langford continued his career after WWII through the late 1960s, but much of his work came in the form of consulting and remodeling rather than producing original designs.

Courses Designed: Lawsonia Links, Leathem Smith Lodge GC*, North Shore Acres CC*, Our CC (Spring Valley CC), Ozaukee CC, West Bend CC (front 9).

Other Notable Architects

David Gill (1919-1991)

Courses Designed: Cherokee CC, Ives Grove GC, North Shore CC – Mequon, River Club of Mequon.

Courses Remodeled or Added to: Blue Mound Golf & CC, Brown’s Lake GC, Brynwood CC (Wisconsin Club’s CC), Meadowbrook CC, Ozaukee CC, Racine CC, West Bend CC, Westmoor CC.

Homer Fieldhouse (1928-2008)

Courses Designed: Camelot CC, Cedar Springs GC, Dodge Point GC, Eagle Bluff GC, Fox Lake CC (added 9), Golden Sands GC, Rock River Hills GC (Horicon Hills).

Rick Jacobson (1958-Present)

Courses Designed: Broadlands GC, Hunter’s Glen GC, Mascoutin GC (Blue), The Club at Strawberry Creek, Thornberry Creek GC (Championship 18 & Iroquois 9).

Note- Courses with an asterisk (*) no longer exist.

Featured

The AV Club

Whether you’re looking for a way to pass time on your work commute or stave away boredom in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, here is a list of podcasts and YouTube channels that I highly recommend checking out. From golf architecture to game improvement, there is something for every type of golfer.

Professional Golf and Other Hijinx

Podcasts

  • The Shotgun Start: The Shotgun Start with Andy Johnson of The Fried Egg and Brendan Porath of SB Nation is a podcast waiting for you early in the morning that quickly blasts through a variety of topics (usually) related to golf and (ideally) relevant to the day. It covers news from the pro tours around the world, amusing and important topics from the amateur game the rest of us play, and some irreverent stuff in between. There will be short interviews, previews, reviews, and dives into the archives. It provides what you need to know on golf through a rapid and fun catch-up discussion.
  • No Laying Up: Fresh, funny discussion of all things golf from the guys at NoLayingUp.com.
  • Get a Grip with Max Homa and Shane Bacon: Hosted by broadcaster Shane Bacon and PGA Tour pro Max Homa, Get a Grip is a golf-centric podcast making light of a rather stuffy sport with legitimate insight into the game. It’s essentially the public golf course of podcasts. The show will offer a look into the PGA Tour from a guy between the ropes week in and week out and have some fun at both his peers and golf fans’ expenses.
  • GOLF’s Subpar: GOLF’s Subpar, hosted by featuring former PGA Tour pro Colt Knost and his long time friend and on course rival Drew Stoltz, pairs colorful segments with in-depth sit-down interviews with the game’s biggest personalities.
  • The Clubhouse with Shane Bacon: Shane Bacon brings you a weekly podcast discussing the world of golf from all angles. Shane speaks with current and former stars from the world, while bringing you the best stories in the game.
  • TrapDraw Podcast: Tron and Randy from No Laying Up chop it up with a wide variety of guests from all corners of the golf world.
  • State Of The Game: State of the Game was one of the first golf podcasts to hit the internet and remains one of the most respected. Hosted by Rod Morri and boasting two of the game’s most important voices in co-hosts Mike Clayton and Geoff Shackelford, State of the Game is the go to podcast for untainted and unfiltered analysis of the game at every level. If you’re looking for swing tips and gear reviews you’ve come to the wrong place but for thoughtful discussion about the big issues facing the game you’ll find this a comfortable home.

Golf Architecture, History & Travel

Podcasts

  • The Fried Egg Golf Podcast: the fried egg dives deep into the topics of professional golf, golf course architecture and amateur golf. Guests range from PGA Tour winners to the world’s greatest architects to great amateur players.
  • Feed The Ball: In the Feed the Ball podcast, writer Derek Duncan discusses golf course design, architecture and the contemporary culture of golf with golf course architects and other luminaries of the game.
  • TalkinGolf History: Hosted by Golf Historian Connor Lewis, the TalkinGolf History podcast dives into a variety of interesting topics from the history of the game.
  • LINKS Golf Podcast: The team at LINKS Golf Media discusses a wide range of topics pertaining to golf travel, course reviews, interviews with leaders of the game, and more.
  • The Good-Good Golf Podcast: Good-Good is the golf show for the serious golfer. We celebrate everything great about the game, from course architecture to promoting public golf.
  • Talking Golf Getaways: Your Golf Getaways Podcast: Talking Golf Getaways is a podcast focusing on golf travel, with hosts Darin Bunch and Mitch Laurance connecting with golf journalists, architects and global golf travelers to talk about their favorite destinations and experiences.
  • The Golfer’s Journal Podcast: Join our host Tom Coyne as he travels the country interviewing the most interesting people in golf.
  • The Bag Drop: Untold Stories in Golf: With over 34,000 golf courses, tens of millions of golfers, and hundreds of thousands supporting the game of golf worldwide, there are endless untold stories about how golf has impacted and shaped lives. Take a listen as we uncover those compelling stories in our podcast.
  • Silver Club Golfing Society Podcast: The SCGS Podcast with hosts Steve Scott and Colin Sheehan is helping connect our listeners and our SCGS members with the amateur game, focusing on the game’s history, its finest competitors, and the amazing grounds over which we play.
  • Scottish Golf Travel: Each week we discuss all aspects of Scottish golf travel and interview golfers about their recent Scottish golf trip. Packed full of useful golf travel hints and tips.

Youtube Channels

Betting and DFS

Podcasts

  • Fantasy Golf Degenerates Podcast: We are the Fantasy Golf Degenerates podcast! We will help you make better decisions with Fantasy/DFS Golf! We provide strategy, picks, analysis and a good time! #HotTakes
  • Gup’s Corner: Fantasy Football, Fantasy Golf, Sports Betting & Contest Guide (PGA, NFL, CFB).
  • The First Cut Golf Podcast: The First Cut takes you inside the ropes of the golf world, on the PGA Tour and beyond. Tournament previews and picks, deep dives into the players and storylines that matter in the sport of golf. Rick Gehman (@RickRunGood) and Greg Ducharme (@therealgfd) join us every week for PGA Tour DFS, betting picks and information you need to know to win your ‘One and Done’ pools. Kyle Porter (@KylePorterCBS) and Mark Immelman (@mark_immelman) bring you the news to know and expert analysis on the world’s most elite players.
  • Pat Mayo Experience: Produced daily, Pat Mayo guides you through the world of NFL, PGA, and UFC betting and Fantasy Sports, along with the latest in TV and Movies.
  • The Action Network Sports Betting Podcast: Under center are hosts like Matthew Freedman, Editor-in-Chief of FantasyLabs, Senior Editor Chris Raybon and renowned sports gambling analyst Stuckey. They’re joined by veteran journalists, gamblers and handicappers like Jason Sobel, Matt Moore, Collin Wilson and “The Oddsmaker” Sean Koerner, The Action Network’s Director of Predictive Analytics and a 3-time #1 ranked FantasyPros NFL expert. Together our crew tackles the hot topics all bettors, fantasy gurus and DFS players want to hear about: analytics-driven projections, injury updates, inefficiencies in betting markets and so much more.

Game Improvement and Golf Technology

podcasts

  • Golf Science Lab: We help golfers understand what it ACTUALLY takes to get better at golf and perform your best. Ignore the BS and cut to truth as we talk with leaders in the industry, from professional golfers, coaches, instructors, biomechanists, researchers and more. Host, Cordie Walker is on a mission to figure out how to improve the way we learn and get better at golf.
  • The Rick Shiels Golf Show: Welcome to Rick Shiels Golf PODCAST, home of Golf Instruction, Golf Coaching, Golf Equipment Reviews, Golf Club Reviews, Golf Course Vlogs, Golf Challenges, Golf Entertainment, Golf Fun and EVERYTHING GOLF!
  • No Putts Given: The #NoPuttsGiven golf podcast is powered by MyGolfSpy: “The World’s Most Extensive Golf Gear Reviews.”
  • GolfWRX Radio: The world’s largest and best online golf community. Expert editorial reviews, breaking golf tour and industry news, what to play, how to play and where to play.

Youtube Channels

Featured

The Ideal “Muni”

A Reflection on the State of Public Golf in America

There are extensive thoughts on what constitutes an ideal golf hole and perhaps Alister MacKenzie said it best, “the ideal hole is surely one that affords the greatest pleasure to the greatest number, gives the fullest advantage to accurate play, stimulates players to improve their game, and never becomes monotonous.” MacKenzie was also very hesitant to label a given hole “ideal” since most holes neglect at least one of his four principles. What goes overlooked is what makes an ideal course. In my opinion, you could have 18 ideal holes and fail to be an ideal course, which may seem counterintuitive, but let me explain why. To be an ideal golf course it needs to meet the following criteria: accessibility, affordability, playability, and variety.

If I were to ask you what the best golf course in the United States was, there is a good chance you’d say Augusta National, Cypress Point, Pine Valley, or the like. Unfortunately, what all these courses have in common is exclusivity, the polar opposite of what should be hailed in the golfing sphere. Don’t get me wrong, from an architectural and pure golf standpoint, it is hard to argue that one of these courses is not the “best” in the country, but on the other hand, 99.9% of golfers will never get the opportunity to play them. If you are a Fortune 500 CEO or an out of touch celebrity, these may seem like ideal golf courses, but to the average Joe, these courses are seen as merely a figment of their imagination. Golf courses in the US need to take a page out of the playbook of the historic clubs of Scotland. There are very few private clubs in the UK as compared to the States and the feeling of community is unmatched. For instance, the most famous golf course in the world, the Old Course at St. Andrews, is not only available for public play, but closes for play on Sunday to become a public park.

Children playing in the bunkers on Sunday at the Old Course. Photo Credit: Kieran Dodds, New York Times

As was the basis for my piece on affordable public golf courses in Wisconsin, the biggest repellent for engaging new golfers, and maintaining current golfers is cost. The average recreational golfer cannot be expected to pay $100+ every time they want to play a round. I understand that some golf courses require larger maintenance budgets, and this budget is reflected in their greens fees. However, in many cases a decrease in daily prices would lead to more revenue for munis due to an increase in the number of rounds played. Part of the affordability argument hinges on public opinion as well, and the PGA Tour is doing the game no favors in that regard. Let me explain bit more what I mean. Week in and week out, events are held at, what the Tour likes to think of as, “exemplary courses” showcasing lush, green turf and green complexes with fewer blemishes than a supermodel (unless you are playing behind Sergio). Many PGA Tour courses even go as far as over-seeding in the spring to hide the dormant Bermuda grass and to provide grass that is unnaturally green for the current time of year. The PGA Tour’s obsession with the color green doesn’t stop there either; they have even been caught boosting the saturation on their video feeds to create the artificial color they love. You may be thinking, “so what?” or “golf courses are supposed to be green,” and therein lies the inherent problem.

Take a look at your lawn in spring or mid-summer and I doubt you will find a deep green hue, unless of course, you spend boatloads of money to maintain it. The grass on a golf course is no different, but the PGA Tour (and magazines like Golf Digest) have altered the narrative to exempt golf courses from the acts of nature. This is a scary narrative to push, and one which can decide the fate of a golf course. Again, we need to take a look at the UK model of golf course maintenance. Last year, Scotland went through one of the driest summers on record, leading to baked out, brown turf. Now, they could have spent ten times their annual maintenance budgets to keep the grass green, but instead, they held on to their roots and let the course play how nature intended, firm and fast.

Baked out grass at Gullane Golf Club during the 2018 Scottish Open. Photo Credit: Getty Images

To many American golfers, this picture may bring a feeling of disgust, but to those of us who value the history AND future of the game, it is a breath of fresh air. If you have a problem with this picture, yet also complain about how expensive greens fees are, you my friend are a hypocrite, and also represent the major problem of American golf. Again, there is no problem with maintaining lush, green turf at Augusta National, Oakmont, or Pebble Beach, as these courses are either highly exclusive or extremely expensive, meaning they have little to no cash flow issues. However, if the focus is to increase the number of people that play golf, we need to accept the fact that our local munis will NOT and should NOT look like Augusta National. It is time we in the public golfing sphere start to embrace the firm and fast conditions that come with less watering and maintenance, and to play the game how it was intended to be played. Now that we have discussed the ideal socioeconomic qualities of public golf, let’s transition to the ideal architectural qualities.

Another terrifying trend that has been popularized by the PGA Tour is the narrowing and lengthening of golf holes. Several architects such as Rees Jones are known for redesigning golf courses to offer a more stern test to the best players in the world, usually by adding length, narrowing fairways, and growing out the rough. Not only has this ruined many great courses from the Renaissance period of golf design, pre-World War II, but it has made a mockery of the game at the highest level. One of my favorite golf quotes is from Alister Mackenzie who said, “Narrow fairways bordered by long grass make bad golfers. They do so by destroying the harmony and continuity of the game, and in causing a stilted and cramped style by destroying all freedom of play.” If we had listened to our elders, the game would not be in the dire position it is today. Narrow fairways and long rough make the game enjoyable for one type of player, the long and straight hitter, an anomaly in the amateur golf scene. An ideal golf course should be enjoyable for all types of players, not just the best of the best. Unfortunately, too many golf courses feature multiple forced carries off the tee, fairways the width of a goal post, water hazards galore (I’m not calling them penalty areas, sorry USGA), bunkers present to only penalize poor golfers, and long rough that only Paul Bunyan could chop through. This is not good golf design, nor is it fun for anyone to play.

It is no wonder golf struggles to recruit new players to the game: it is expensive and often times unenjoyable. Thankfully, there have been a number of architects who have taken on projects to improve courses with these horrendous characteristics, such as King-Collins Design at Sweeten’s Cove and the duo of Riley Johns and Keith Rhebb at Winter Park (see featured image above). Many people in golf architecture roll their eyes when they hear the overused term, “width and angles”, but despite its overuse and misuse, we must not lose sight of its importance. Long and narrow golf holes remove most, if not all of the strategy from the game (other than hitting it long and straight). It must not be forgotten that there are many ways to test a golfer’s skill without bringing him/her to their slow, painful death by way of long rough and water hazards. Uneven fairways, grass bunkers, and sloping green approaches and green complexes provide a much more enjoyable and no less difficult challenge to the golfer than a water hazard or pot bunker.

The last criterion for the ideal public golf course is variety. In the words of A.W. Tillinghast, “A round of golf should present 18 inspirations. Every hole must have individuality.” It is not enough to just throw in a bunker or water hazard here and there and call each hole unique if the fundamentals of each hole remains the same. There are three schools of golf design: heroic, penal, and strategic, and it is imperative that a course has a mix between the three schools. Too many penal holes will have players returning to the clubhouse to buy a dozen more balls and too many heroic holes will bore the golfer that does not or can not pull off the shots required. To me, there is room for strategy in every hole, and every hole should be laid out with a strategy in mind. Once a strategy is determined, a heroic or penal feature can be implemented based on the strategy employed by the golfer. Far too often though, golf courses lack all three of these design principles and the holes blend together. The public golf courses I grew up playing had very few memorable holes and became monotonous by the back nine. As Charles Blair MacDonald once said, “Variety is not only ‘the spice of life’ but it is the very foundation of golfing architecture.” It is a shame that so many courses have evolved into over-treed, narrow plots of land that lack any uniqueness, or were designed like that in the first place.

It is time we demand more from the golf courses we frequent, and by more, I really mean less. Fewer trees, water hazards, selectively penal bunkers and less rough, watering, and maintenance. It is somewhat comical, but also frustrating, that most of the features that were intended to spruce up and provide character to the golf course have done just the opposite. PGA Tour Commissioner Jay Monahan can say golf has never been in a better place all day long, but we as the golfing public know better. With great knowledge comes great responsibility, and we must fight to change the public golfing scene and put an emphasis on accessibility, affordability, playability, and variety. The power is in our hands and the time is now to propel change.

The Grading Scale

How I rate Wisconsin golf courses

0-10: The worst of the worst golf courses. A course that I could never, in good conscience, recommend spending money to play.

11-20: An extremely basic golf course that shows clear signs of poor architectural design and/or maintenance neglect. There has to be somewhere better to play in the area.

21-30: A poorly designed or maintained course that lacks any redeeming qualities. A course that is best played with a few buddies and a lot of beers.

31-40: A mediocre golf course that lacks pretty much any architectural interest, but there may be a few elements of the course that grab your attention.

41-50: Your average, run-of-the-mill course in the state of Wisconsin, of which there are many.

51-60: A somewhat interesting course that either provides some architecturally distinctive holes or has scenic views that gives the course some intrigue. An enjoyable place to play golf.

61-70: Much better than the average golf course in the state, and is worth playing if you are in the area, but is not somewhere I would travel over an hour to play.

71-80: A very good golf course that you should definitely check out if you are in that region of the state. The course is well-maintained, has sound design principles, and is home to several interesting holes.

81-90: One of the very best courses in the state that is worth the trip from wherever you live in the state, but isn’t necessarily a course I would cross state lines to play.

91-100: A tremendous golf course that is at the top of the top tier of courses in the state, and one of the best courses in the country. A course that you must see at least once in your life if you are a Wisconsin resident and is worth a cross-country trip to see.

NOTE: The scale I use to rate golf courses is skewed towards Wisconsin, so a score in the 80s on my scale may fall in the 60s-70s when compared to courses in the entire country or in the 50s-60s when compared to golf courses worldwide.

The Book Club

Whether you consider yourself a recreational golfer, competitive golfer, or architecture enthusiast (like myself), this compilation of readings has something for you.

Architecture

Primers

The Anatomy of a Golf Course: The Art of Golf Architecture by Tom Doak

Grounds for Golf by Geoff Shackelford and Gil Hanse

Deeper dive

Methods of Early Golf Architecture: The Selected Writings of Alister Mackenzie, H.S. Colt, and A.W. Tillinghast (Vol. 1)

Methods of Early Golf Architecture: The Selected Writings of C.B. Macdonald, George C. Thomas, and Robert Hunter (Vol. 2)

Golf Architecture in America by George Thomas

The Links by Robert Hunter

Golf Architecture by Alister MacKenzie

The Spirit of St. Andrews by Alister MacKenzie

Some Essays on Golf-Course Architecture by H.S. Colt and C.H. Alison

Scotland’s Gift: Golf by C.B. Macdonald

The Evolution of Golf Course Design by Keith Cutten

Tom Doak’s Little Red Book of Golf Course Architecture by Tom Doak

The Confidential Guide to Golf Courses (Vols. 1-5) by Tom Doak

Golf Has Never Failed Me by Donald Ross

The Architectural Side of Golf by H.N. Wethered and T. Simpson

Miscellaneous Golf Reads

The Match: The Day the Game of Golf Changed Forever by Mark Frost

Missing Links by Rick Reilly

Paper Tiger by Tom Coyne

A Course Called Ireland: A Long Walk In Search of a Country, a Pint, and the Next Tee by Tom Coyne

A Course Called Scotland: Searching the Home of Golf for the Secret to Its Game by Tom Coyne

Slaying the Tiger: A Year Inside the Ropes on the New PGA Tour by Shane Ryan

Tiger Woods by Jeff Benedict and Armen Keteyian

A Good Walk Spoiled: Days and Nights on the PGA Tour by John Feinstein

The Swinger by Michael Bamberger and Alan Shipnuck

Men in Green by Michael Bamberger

Preferred Lies: And Other True Golf Stories by Michael Clayton

The Big Miss: My Years Coaching Tiger Woods by Hank Haney

The Eternal Summer by Curt Sampson

Wisconsin’s Greatest Values

One of the greatest barriers of golf for the masses is price. Unfortunately, the widely held belief is that the more expensive the course, the better it is. Although it is generally true that more expensive courses have larger maintenance budgets and consequently better conditioning, price doesn’t tell the whole story. In this piece, I lay out several of the state’s most interesting and affordable courses that anyone can play.

Note- all rates mentioned are for walking, though some courses have carts included (if you must). Courses will continue to be added to the list. All courses are listed in the following format, “Course Name (peak rate) – Location – Architect(s)” 

Lawsonia Links (peak rate – $95) – Green Lake – William Langford & Theodore Moreau

Back nine at Lawsonia Links. Photo Credit: The Golf Courses of Lawsonia

If you haven’t played the Links course at Lawsonia, stop what you are doing right now and make a tee time. For a quarter the price of Whistling Straits or Erin Hills, Lawsonia offers an experience just as good if not better than the state’s giants. With bold contours, stunning green complexes, and width that provides playability for all, Lawsonia Links is a must play.

Lawsonia Woodlands (peak rate- $95) – Green Lake – Rocky Roquemore

The treacherous downhill par-3 3rd. Photo Credit: The Golf Courses of Lawsonia

Overshadowed by its older sibling, and rightfully so, the Woodlands course at Lawsonia offers a great complement to the superb Links course. It is a more traditional “American-style”, tree-lined course but features some very dramatic holes, and is home to an abundance of wildlife. If you are only playing one round in the Green Lake area, the Links course should be your first choice, but if you are spending a few days in the area, be sure to check out the Woodlands course.

Glacier Wood Golf Club (peak rate – $50) – Iola – Larry Packard/Art Johnson

The exhilarating par-3 12th at Glacier Wood

Set in the remote town of Iola, Glacier Wood won’t wow you with its brilliant architecture, but its wonderful routing and series of elevation changes make it a great place to play.

Broadlands Golf Club (peak rate- $47) – North Prairie – Rick Jacobson

The great risk/reward par-4 3rd. From the elevated tee, the short par 4 is reachable for the medium-long hitter, but it requires taking on the out of bounds area to the left of the fairway, as well as the water to the right, which narrows near the green. A mid iron shot just over the left fairway bunkers leaves a manageable wedge shot, but the further right from the bunkers, the more the water comes into play on the wedge shot. Photo Credit: Broadlands Golf Club.

The wide open, links-style layout is a treat to play, especially in late summer when conditions are very firm and fast. The course poses many strategic questions, and the wind poses a challenge for even the best of players.

Washington County Golf Course (peak rate- $60) – Hartford – Arthur Hills

An aerial view of Washington County Golf Course. Photo Credit: Golf Advisor

Set in the heart of the historic Kettle Moraine, Washington County Golf Course is one of the finest municipally-run golf courses in the state. The rolling terrain gives rise to subtle, natural contours that can pose a challenge in the fairways and around the greens. It’s wide fairways make it playable for all and the conditioning is always top notch.

Peninsula State Park (peak rate- $44) – Ephraim (Door County) – Larry Packard

The 10th hole overlooking Lake Michigan. Photo Credit: Peninsula State Park
The stunning downhill tee shot to the 17th. Photo Credit: Peninsula State Park
The unique 69-yard 8th hole. Photo Credit: Reddit u/ThetrueGamerview

One of the most unique properties that renowned Wisconsin architect Larry Packard ever got a chance to work on, Peninsula State Park offers dramatic elevation changes and stunning views of Lake Michigan. It is far from the best Packard design, and leaves a lot to be desired from an architectural standpoint, but the breathtaking landscape provides a very fun place to play golf.

Brown County Golf Course (peak rate- $36) – Hobart – Larry Packard

The short par-4 13th, with water in play on both your tee shot and approach shot. Photo Credit: Brown County Golf Course

Growing up in Brown County, I have played Brown County Golf Course dozens of times. It features some great dogleg holes, most notably the par-5 6th, which presents the golfer with many different options off the tee. Recent turf renovations have improved putting surfaces and fairways, but what is truly needed is tree and pond removal to restore the course to the way Packard intended it to play. That being said, Brown County is a great place to play, especially if you are in town for a Packers game, as it is less than 15 minutes from Lambeau Field.

Spring Valley Country Club (peak rate- $20) – Salem – William Langford and Theodore Moreau

Unique grass filled bunkers guard the green at Spring Valley. Photo Credit: golfwisconsin.com

It is amazing how a course designed by one of the best tandem of architects from the Golden Age can go so overlooked. Prior to Andy Johnson of the Fried Egg’s article “Bang for your buck: Wisconsin Edition” even I hadn’t heard of it. Spring Valley is overgrown and could greatly benefit from a cleanup, but thankfully the original design remains unaltered. The course features Langford and Moreau’s staples, such as bold contouring and interesting green complexes. If you can appreciate the golf course for what it was and could be, setting aside the overgrown appearance, then there isn’t a better way to spend $20.

Eagle Springs Golf Resort (peak rate- $18.75/9 holes) – Eagle – A.G. Spalding

Volcano Hole at Eagle Springs. Photo Credit: Eagle Springs Golf Resort

In the early-1920s, A.G. Spalding (former Major League pitcher and manager) was hired to redesign the existing golf course built in 1893. Apparently Spalding’s directives were to design the first two holes and let nature dictate the rest of the 18-hole layout. Unfortunately, due to the Great Depression, the course was reduced to 9 holes. Despite only being a 9 hole course, Eagle Springs packs a punch that is unmatched by most 18 hole courses in the state. For instance, the “Volcano” 2nd hole is among the most astonishing par-3’s you will see anywhere. It’s a shame this was the only course Spalding ever designed. Despite the scruffy conditions, Eagle Springs is a must-add for anyone looking for a quick, fun nine in the southeast part of the state.

Forest Hills Golf Course (peak rate- $20)– La Crosse – Rick Jacobson (2015 redesign)

View of the bluffs from the 16th green at Forest Hills. Photo Credit: Forest Hills Golf

Forest Hills Golf Course from above looks like just another tree-lined, parkland golf course, of which there are many in the state of Wisconsin. However, from ground level it is clearly so much more. Views of the neighboring bluffs can be seen from nearly every hole and many of the holes feature strategic mounds and natural contours that make short game shots very interesting. It could definitely use a tree removal project and green expansion, as the playing corridors are narrow and the putting surfaces are tiny. Never the less, Forest Hills is a neat place to play golf and to take in the views of the magnificent bluffs.

Big Fish Golf Club (peak rate- $43) – Hayward – Pete Dye

The par-3 9th hole at Big Fish. Photo Credit: Peter Wong

When Pete Dye designed the courses at Kohler, he was said to have received an unlimited budget, and still exceeded it. That was not the case at Big Fish Golf Club, as the owners had a modest budget that kept in check Dye’s propensity to create some of the unnecessary aesthetic features that he loved (such as the 967 bunkers on the Straits course at Whistling Straits). Less in-your-face than either of the courses at Whistling Straits (and without the stunning views of Lake Michigan), Dye’s routing at Big Fish stacks up toe-to-toe with its higher priced siblings. It is a tale of two nines at Big Fish, where the front nine resides on a wide-open, flat piece of property and the back nine meanders through mature trees, yet maintains width and playability. Being in the northwest portion of the state, Hayward isn’t exactly the home of entertainment, but if you are looking to play a Pete Dye course that is every bit as good as his Kohler layouts and want to still be able to feed your family, Big Fish is a must-see.

If you have a course that you think should be on the list, fill out the form below, and I will take a look.